Skip to content

Things read, heard, watched and found. Now and then a thought of my own.

Timeline
Book

Heretics for Hire

JA Westenberg

1 highlight · Nov 2026

Find contrarian ideas that are both well-supported and valuable to clients, rather than simply voicing personal complaints. Charge for the importance of the decisions your advice helps clients make, and accept that being right early may bring criticism. As a heresy becomes common knowledge, update your services and find a new insight.

21 Nov 2026

When an organization is about to adopt a bad strategy, they already have people on staff who know that the plan is bad. The engineers know that the launch date is unrealistic. The sales team knows that the new pricing will drive away the best clients. The analysts three levels down know the numbers from the company they plan to acquire don’t add up. And, in fact, these people often point this out.

The executive leadership then thanks these people, ignores them, and labels them “not a team player.” Some of these people get fired. The rest learn to shut up.

Then, a year later, the same leadership hires an outside organization, pays them a lot of money, and finds out what the engineer could have told them for free.

This happens for reasons of self-preservation. When an insider dissents, leadership sees it as an attempt to seize power or disloyalty. When they hear they are wrong from their own organization, it is embarrassing. But when they hear it from their own consultant, it is what they paid for. Outsiders who disagree aren’t threatening. They aren’t after anyone’s job and will be gone in six weeks. It’s much easier for leadership to hear from outsiders what they cannot afford to hear from their own staff.

A letter every Monday

The week’s reading, highlights and the odd thought of my own, in one email.

One email a week. Unsubscribe with one click. See a sample